Supreme Court Considers Arizona Law Targeting Undocumented Immigrant Workers

December 13, 2010 7:07 am 2 comments
Supreme Court Considers Arizona Law Targeting Undocumented Immigrant Workers

Arizona Governor Jan Brewer.

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court grappled last week over whether the state of Arizona has authority to implement standards and penalties on employers who knowingly hire undocumented workers.

The hour-long hearing on Dec. 8 put Arizona, once again, at the center of a conflict between federal and state government over immigration enforcement.

The eight participating justices heard arguments on Chamber of Commerce v. Whiting, a case highlighting the Legal Arizona Workers Act. The bill was signed into law in 2007 by former Arizona Gov. Janet Napolitano, who now serves as Secretary of Homeland Security.

The law requires all employers to participate in E-Verify, an employment verification database system. The law also allows the state to revoke business licenses from those who intentionally hire undocumented workers. Involvement in E-Verify is voluntary under federal law.

“The bottom line is that we believe if the (federal) government isn’t going to do the job, Arizona is going to do the job and we are faced with a crisis,” current Gov. Jan Brewer told reporters after the hearing. “In regards to today’s hearing, certainly we do issue licenses and if we giveth, we can taketh away and that’s what we’re hoping.”

E-verify is an internet-based system that allows employers to use information reported on an I-9 Form, Employment Eligibility Verification, to determine an individual’s authorization to work in the United States. It is limited to new hires.

Civil rights groups argued that the law fails to offer protections against discrimination.

Karen Tumlin, the managing attorney at the National Immigration Law Center and council for the petitioners against Arizona’s sanctions law, said the E-verify system contains scores of errors and it disproportionately affects people of color.

The system issues “tentative non-confirmation” checks to applicants whom employers suspect are undocumented before confirming their legal status. Tumlin said that in some cases tentative non-confirmations have turned out to be incorrect, which has the effect of discriminating against people who are legal residents.

Other arguments were made against state preemption because it conflicts with a 1986 federal ruling prohibiting states from taking action against employers unless they were convicted of violating federal law. A clause in the Immigration Reform and Control Act, however, allows state governments latitude to take civil action when licensing businesses.

“The bottom line here is this is a statute that was enacted 21 years ago and structured the relationships between the federal government and the state government,” said Carter G. Phillips, the Washington attorney who represented the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. “Maricopa County is going to send off people to investigate and try to adjudicate these claims.”

He added that the balance Congress struck between the protections on both sides will be “completely dashed.”

The Justices are expected to reach a decision on the case early next year. Justice Elena Kagan recused herself from participating.

If the Supreme Court decides to uphold the state law, it would give states broader authority to set and enforce immigration policy.

Arizona Governor Jan Brewer believes that cracking down on undocumented workers will help improve her state’s sagging economy.

Brewer told Hispanic Link that SB1070, which gives the state immigration enforcement powers, hasn’t seriously damaged Arizona’s economy. Although there were some conventions cancelled, the hotel and tourism industry is moving forward, she said, adding the undocumented workforce has cost the state a lot of money.

Raisa Camargo is a reporter with Hispanic Link News Service.

Image: Wiki Commons.


  • now once again the none american will face the hardship in USA.very strict rule and law of immigration day by day. now no any Asian will think to go USA,.

Leave a Reply

Other News

  • Caribbean Cuba News Briefs North America United Nations United States Transcript: Obama’s Cuba Speech

    Transcript: Obama’s Cuba Speech

    Below is a full transcript of President Obama’s speech on Cuba. A video of the speech can be found following the transcript. OBAMA: Good afternoon. Today, the United States of America is changing its relationship with the people of Cuba. In the most significant changes in our policy in more than fifty years, we will end an outdated approach that, for decades has failed to advance our interests, and instead, we will begin to normalize relations between our two countries. […]

    Read more →
  • Caribbean Cuba News Briefs North America United States U.S., Cuba to Restore Diplomatic Ties, But Embargo Remains

    U.S., Cuba to Restore Diplomatic Ties, But Embargo Remains

    The U.S. and Cuba will work to normalize diplomatic relations for the first time since 1961, President Obama said Wednesday, a major shift in policy that nonetheless falls short of the outright removal of the U.S. economic blockade on the island. The announcement comes after Cuba’s release of American aid contractor Alan Gross from prison, in exchange for the release of three Cubans jailed in the state of Florida for espionage — a sign of good faith between the two […]

    Read more →
  • Brazil Southern Cone Today in Latin America Charges Filed Against Brazilian Lawmaker After Rape Remarks

    Charges Filed Against Brazilian Lawmaker After Rape Remarks

    Top Story — Brazil’s attorney general filed charges of incitement to rape against Brazilian congressman Jair Bolsonaro after he made violent comments to a fellow lawmaker in Congress last Tuesday, saying, “I wouldn’t rape you. You’re not worth it.” It is the second time Bolsonaro, a right-wing representative from Rio de Janeiro state known for misogynist remarks, has used the word inappropriately in Congress. Bolsonaro’s comments were directed at Maria do Rosário, a former secretary of human rights, as she […]

    Read more →
  • Central America Dispatches Honduras Alternatives to Detention Leave Some Honduran Immigrants in “Shackles”

    Alternatives to Detention Leave Some Honduran Immigrants in “Shackles”

    NEW YORK — On an average weekday Eva, a 39-year-old woman from Honduras, never leaves a 15-block radius in the Bronx. From bringing her two children to school, to taking English classes, visiting her church and running errands, her life is mapped on a now-familiar route — one that is precisely tracked by the electronic monitoring device strapped to her ankle. Eva, who asked to have her name changed because she is currently going through deportation hearings, received the device […]

    Read more →
  • Caribbean Haiti Today in Latin America Haitian Prime Minister Defends Record After Resignation

    Haitian Prime Minister Defends Record After Resignation

    Top Story — Haiti’s Prime Minister Laurent Lamothe spoke out on Monday, defending his legacy after an independent commission set up by President Michel Martelly pressured him to resign over the weekend. Several other ministers also stepped down amid a political standoff that has been years in the making. Lamothe’s resignation comes in the wake of continued anti-government protests demanding elections that have been delayed since 2011. On Friday, U.N. peacekeepers were seen firing at a crowd of protesters while […]

    Read more →
  • Mexico North America Today in Latin America Mexican Federal Police Implicated in Student Killings

    Mexican Federal Police Implicated in Student Killings

    Top Story — Federal authorities in Mexico appear to have participated in the September attack on a group of teacher trainees in the state of Guerrero, contrary to prior government claims, according to an investigation released Saturday by Proceso magazine. Proceso’s investigation reportedly uncovered state documents that show federal police officers knew the attack was ongoing and even shot at the students as they travelled on several buses toward a protest event in Iguala, Guerrero. After that attack, 43 of […]

    Read more →
  • Caribbean Cuba News Briefs Cuban Laws May Have Changed, But the Jokes Haven’t

    Cuban Laws May Have Changed, But the Jokes Haven’t

    In 2010, I found myself among hundreds of heeled and hairsprayed Cubans in Havana’s Teatro Karl Marx waiting for the start of the Premios Lucas — a sort of MTV Video Music Awards of Cuba. Hosted by beloved comedian Luis Silva and with performances by pop, rock and reggaeton groups, “Los Lucas” was sure to be a revelatory peek into the popular culture consumption of my Cuban peers. Los Lucas did not disappoint. Every moment of the two-hour show was […]

    Read more →
  • Andes Argentina Colombia News Briefs Southern Cone Latin American Environmentalists Call For End To Fracking

    Latin American Environmentalists Call For End To Fracking

    Latin American environmental activists called for an end to fracking this week, as international leaders gathered in Lima, Peru, for the United Nations summit on climate change. Researchers and protestors from Mexico, Argentina, Brazil, Bolivia and Colombia met in Lima over the last two weeks to share their concerns about hydraulic fracturing, or “fracking,” in their countries, and released a public statement criticizing the practice on Monday supported by 71 environmental organizations. “It is at the Conference of the Parties […]

    Read more →
  • Brazil Southern Cone Today in Latin America Brazil Charges 36 Over Petrobras Corruption Scandal

    Brazil Charges 36 Over Petrobras Corruption Scandal

    Top Story — Brazilian prosecutors on Thursday filed criminal charges against 36 people for alleged involvement in a massive kickback scheme at oil giant Petrobras, Brazil’s largest company, which is partially state-run. The indictments include top executives at six of the country’s major engineering firms and two former Petrobras directors. The 36 charged are accused of money laundering, corruption, and forming a criminal organization. Prosecutors allege that billions of dollars were paid as bribes to Petrobras by several engineering companies […]

    Read more →
  • Central America Nicaragua Today in Latin America Nicaraguan Protesters March Against Canal Project

    Nicaraguan Protesters March Against Canal Project

    Top Story — Thousands marched through the Nicaraguan capital of Managua on Wednesday to protest the construction of a transoceanic canal, two weeks ahead of the project’s start-date. The demonstrators — may of whom travelled to the capital from villages along the canal’s proposed route — fear they will be displaced without adequate compensation. Critics say the proposed canal could have lasting consequences for the environment and for local indigenous communities. About half of the canal’s route will fall inside […]

    Read more →