Supreme Court Considers Arizona Law Targeting Undocumented Immigrant Workers

December 13, 2010 7:07 am 2 comments
Supreme Court Considers Arizona Law Targeting Undocumented Immigrant Workers

Arizona Governor Jan Brewer.

WASHINGTON — The U.S. Supreme Court grappled last week over whether the state of Arizona has authority to implement standards and penalties on employers who knowingly hire undocumented workers.

The hour-long hearing on Dec. 8 put Arizona, once again, at the center of a conflict between federal and state government over immigration enforcement.

The eight participating justices heard arguments on Chamber of Commerce v. Whiting, a case highlighting the Legal Arizona Workers Act. The bill was signed into law in 2007 by former Arizona Gov. Janet Napolitano, who now serves as Secretary of Homeland Security.

The law requires all employers to participate in E-Verify, an employment verification database system. The law also allows the state to revoke business licenses from those who intentionally hire undocumented workers. Involvement in E-Verify is voluntary under federal law.

“The bottom line is that we believe if the (federal) government isn’t going to do the job, Arizona is going to do the job and we are faced with a crisis,” current Gov. Jan Brewer told reporters after the hearing. “In regards to today’s hearing, certainly we do issue licenses and if we giveth, we can taketh away and that’s what we’re hoping.”

E-verify is an internet-based system that allows employers to use information reported on an I-9 Form, Employment Eligibility Verification, to determine an individual’s authorization to work in the United States. It is limited to new hires.

Civil rights groups argued that the law fails to offer protections against discrimination.

Karen Tumlin, the managing attorney at the National Immigration Law Center and council for the petitioners against Arizona’s sanctions law, said the E-verify system contains scores of errors and it disproportionately affects people of color.

The system issues “tentative non-confirmation” checks to applicants whom employers suspect are undocumented before confirming their legal status. Tumlin said that in some cases tentative non-confirmations have turned out to be incorrect, which has the effect of discriminating against people who are legal residents.

Other arguments were made against state preemption because it conflicts with a 1986 federal ruling prohibiting states from taking action against employers unless they were convicted of violating federal law. A clause in the Immigration Reform and Control Act, however, allows state governments latitude to take civil action when licensing businesses.

“The bottom line here is this is a statute that was enacted 21 years ago and structured the relationships between the federal government and the state government,” said Carter G. Phillips, the Washington attorney who represented the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. “Maricopa County is going to send off people to investigate and try to adjudicate these claims.”

He added that the balance Congress struck between the protections on both sides will be “completely dashed.”

The Justices are expected to reach a decision on the case early next year. Justice Elena Kagan recused herself from participating.

If the Supreme Court decides to uphold the state law, it would give states broader authority to set and enforce immigration policy.

Arizona Governor Jan Brewer believes that cracking down on undocumented workers will help improve her state’s sagging economy.

Brewer told Hispanic Link that SB1070, which gives the state immigration enforcement powers, hasn’t seriously damaged Arizona’s economy. Although there were some conventions cancelled, the hotel and tourism industry is moving forward, she said, adding the undocumented workforce has cost the state a lot of money.

Raisa Camargo is a reporter with Hispanic Link News Service.

Image: Wiki Commons.

2 Comments

  • now once again the none american will face the hardship in USA.very strict rule and law of immigration day by day. now no any Asian will think to go USA,.

Leave a Reply


Other News

  • Argentina Southern Cone Today in Latin America Case Against President Cristina Fernández Dismissed

    Case Against President Cristina Fernández Dismissed

    Top Story — A federal judge in Argentina has dismissed a criminal complaint against President Cristina Fernández that has captivated the country since the prosecutor working on the case, Alberto Nisman, was found dead in his apartment in January, just hours before he was to testify against Fernández. Ruling that Nisman’s case was not sufficient to warrant a criminal investigation of Fernández, Judge Daniel Rafecas said that there was “not even circumstantial evidence” against the president. Nisman, whose case was […]

    Read more →
  • Brazil Southern Cone Today in Latin America Truckers’ Protest Snags Brazil Highways, Economy

    Truckers’ Protest Snags Brazil Highways, Economy

    Truck drivers in Brazil continued blocking roads across much of the country on Wednesday, and the government offer aimed at halting the protests did not immediately receive a reply, Reuters reported. Drivers in at least 10 states are protesting a tax on diesel fuel put in place by the government of President Dilma Rousseff, amid a larger effort to close a wide budget deficit. The widespread blockades, which have resulted in shortages of food and fuel and hampered Brazil’s exports, […]

    Read more →
  • Andes Today in Latin America Venezuela Outrage Across Venezuela as 14-Year-Old Killed During Protest

    Outrage Across Venezuela as 14-Year-Old Killed During Protest

    Top Story — Venezuelan police fatally shot a student during demonstrations on Tuesday in the city of San Cristóbal, sparking intensified protests in the city and calls for a new anti-government rally, The Associated Press reported. The shooting, which members of the ruling socialist government including President Nicolás Maduro quickly painted as an unfortunate accident, comes amid a time of increased tension in Venezuela, as a major opposition figure was stripped of his seat on the same day in connection […]

    Read more →
  • Caribbean Cuba Today in Latin America More Than 100 Cuban Dissidents Arrested Ahead of Second Round of Talks

    More Than 100 Cuban Dissidents Arrested Ahead of Second Round of Talks

    Top Story — The assistant secretary of state and highest-ranking U.S. diplomat for Latin America, Roberta Jacobson, expressed concern over the silencing of dissident voices in Cuba, following reports that over 100 anti-government protesters were arrested over the weekend. Fifty-three members of the prominent dissident group Ladies in White were arrested on Sunday — according to the group’s leader Berta Soler — along with 36 other activists. The leader of the Cuban Commission for Human Rights and National Reconciliation, Elizardo […]

    Read more →
  • Andes Peru Today in Latin America Espionage Allegations Threaten Relations Between Peru and Chile

    Espionage Allegations Threaten Relations Between Peru and Chile

    Top Story — The diplomatic crisis between Peru and Chile over a suspected spying plot intensified over the weekend as Peruvian President Ollanta Humala sent a strongly worded letter to Chilean officials and announced that he would withdraw the country’s ambassador from Chile. Ollanta’s letter and statement follow revelations last week that three Peruvian naval officials are suspected of spying for Chile. Two of the three officers are currently standing trial for treason in a Peruvian military court, while the […]

    Read more →
  • North America Today in Latin America Great Reads — February 22, 2015

    Great Reads — February 22, 2015

    Killing in Washington State Offers ‘Ferguson’ Moment for Hispanics Julie Turkewitz and Richard A. Oppel Jr. The New York Times. February 16, 2015. On the afternoon of Feb. 10, Antonio Zambrano-Montes — a 35-year-old Hispanic resident of the agricultural town of Pasco, Washington — reportedly threw rocks at cars and police officers. Zambrano-Montes then ran away, with three officers right behind him. A graphic video shot by an onlooker captured what happened next: Zambrano-Montes turned around and put his hands […]

    Read more →
  • Andes Today in Latin America Venezuela Caracas Mayor Arrested Over Alleged U.S.-Backed Conspiracy

    Caracas Mayor Arrested Over Alleged U.S.-Backed Conspiracy

    Top Story — Venezuelan intelligence agents arrested Caracas mayor and opposition figure Antonio Ledezma on Thursday, after officials accused him of plotting a coup against the government of President Nicolás Maduro. Ledezma’s arrest follows declarations made in recent days by Maduro that a group of air force officers were colluding with the local opposition and with the United States to overthrow the socialist government, which has been beset by difficulties including economic woes connected to the steep fall in global […]

    Read more →
  • Argentina Southern Cone Today in Latin America Thousands March in Argentina One Month After Prosecutor’s Death

    Thousands March in Argentina One Month After Prosecutor’s Death

    Buenos Aires was the scene of a major protest on Wednesday as thousands held a rally to express their dissatisfaction with President Cristina Fernández’s handling of the investigation into the mysterious death of prosecutor Alberto Nisman, The Associated Press reported. While estimates on attendance were not immediately available, the march was one of the largest since Nisman was found dead one month ago in his apartment of a single gunshot wound to the head. Fernández made veiled references to the […]

    Read more →
  • North America Today in Latin America United States Obama Reluctantly Complies With Judge’s Injunction on Immigration Order

    Obama Reluctantly Complies With Judge’s Injunction on Immigration Order

    Top Story — President Barack Obama was forced to suspend on Tuesday the first phase of his executive order on immigration, which would have gone into effect Wednesday, after a Texas federal judge filed an injunction late on Monday that, for the time being, blocks it from taking effect. Judge Andrew S. Hanen’s ruling will bar up to 270,000 undocumented immigrants who arrived in the United States as children from applying for protection from deportation, challenging Obama’s November executive order […]

    Read more →
  • News Briefs North America Transcript: Obama’s Statement to the Press Over Immigration Ruling

    Transcript: Obama’s Statement to the Press Over Immigration Ruling

    On Tuesday, President Barack Obama was forced to suspend the first phase of his executive order on immigration, which would have gone into effect Wednesday, after a Texas federal judge filed an injunction that, for the time being, blocks it from taking effect. The following are Obama’s remarks to the press in reaction to the decision by Judge Andrew S. Hanen of the Southern District of Texas. “I disagree with the Texas judge’s ruling, and the Justice Department will appeal. […]

    Read more →