Mexican drug war spokesman Alejandro Poiré.
Latin America: Week in Review, Mexico

Calderón’s Proposal To Try Mexican Soldiers In Civilian Courts Doesn’t Go Far Enough, Human Rights Groups Say

October 20, 2010 By Staff

Mexican drug war spokesman Alejandro Poiré.

Today in Latin America

Top Story — Human rights groups criticized a proposal by Mexican President Felipe Calderón to try soldiers in civilian courts, saying the law would not go far enough, The Los Angeles Times reported on Tuesday.

The proposal, which has been submitted to Mexico’s Congress, would require civilian trials for soldiers charged with rape, torture and forced disappearances. Mexican soldiers accused of such crimes currently stand trial in military courts.

But the law would exclude other serious crimes that have tainted the Mexican military’s reputation in recent years, including unlawful detention and extrajudicial killings, The L.A. Times reports.

“Any reform of the military code should include civilian jurisdiction for all human rights abuses, not just a selection of certain abuses,” said Maureen Meyer, of the Washington Office on Latin America.

Mexico’s drug war spokesman Alejandro Poiré defended the measure, saying “This proposed reform doesn’t eliminate military jurisdiction — it modernizes it.”

Other human rights groups, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, and the U.N. high commissioner for human rights, issued statements urging the Mexican congressmen to expand the scope of the law.

The decision to alter military jurisdiction over violent crimes committed by soldiers against civilians was prompted by a November ruling by the Inter-American Court of Human Rights that condemned the Mexican government for failing to adequately investigate the 1974 disappearance of a guerrilla sympathizer, The Associated Press reports.

Just Published at the Latin America News Dispatch

  • With it the nation’s toughest state immigration law, Arizona has taken center stage in the national debate about immigration as the midterm elections approach. Molly O’Toole reports from Arizona in a three-part series.
  • The threat to freedom of the press posed by Mexico’s drug cartels begs a bilateral response, a panel of journalists and press freedom groups said in New York Tuesday. Andrew O’Reilly has more.
  • Hispanic groups are attempting to mobilize voters amid concerns that voter turnout will be low for midterm elections.

Headlines from the Western Hemisphere

North America

  • Twenty-six undocumented immigrants were apprehended over the weekend trying to reach the U.S. coast on water skis, a luxury sailboat and a small fishing vessel, only to be intercepted by federal agents, U.S. Customs and Border Protection said Monday.
  • A California native who went missing in Mexico nearly two months ago was found dead over the weekend, the victim of an apparent homicide, a Mexican state official said Tuesday.
  • A suspect wanted in the 2001 shooting death of an Arizona teenager has been arrested in Mexico.


Central America


Southern Cone


Subscribe to Today in Latin America by Email

1 Comment

[…] new Mexican law proposed by President Calderon to require soldiers to be tried in civilian courts for rape, […]

Comments are closed.